Bombay Duck Pickle Cafe

327 State St, Carthage, NY 13619, United States
+1 315-493-9025
$$$ Cafe
(84 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

Welcome to Bombay Duck Pickle Cafe, a delightful culinary gem nestled in Carthage, NY. This cozy cafe, located at 327 State St, offers a refreshing departure from the norm, inviting you to indulge your taste buds in a symphony of ethnic flavors that are both exciting and comforting.

The atmosphere here is warm and inviting, with a charming decor that reflects the eclectic nature of the menu. With only 11 seats available, the cafe provides an intimate dining experience where every meal feels special. The owners, Allison and Ralph, are dedicated hosts who bring a touch of hospitality that makes every guest feel right at home. As you enter, the aroma of spices and freshly baked bread wafts through the air, promising a delightful dining experience.

At Bombay Duck Pickle Cafe, the menu is a canvas that changes daily, inspired by the seasons and influenced by global flavors. You may find yourself savoring a Turkish appetizer spread, an enchanting dish that transports you back to distant travels, or perhaps one of their sensational lemongrass soups, renowned for its balance of fragrant herbs and deep, comforting flavors. Customers rave about the red curry coconut bisque, which has been described as “hitting the spot” for its rich and satisfying profile. Each dish is thoughtfully crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients and a touch of the owners’ personal flair.

Customer reviews tell the story of a cafe that is more than just a place to eat. Miguel Ortiz describes it as “an oasis of exciting ethnic flavors amidst a desert of monotonous American fare,” while Kathryn Jeurissen emphasizes the freshness of the seasonal menu, capable of delighting every palate, from meat-lovers to those with dietary restrictions. Repeatedly, patrons mention the incredible attention to detail that goes into each dish – a sentiment echoed by Lawrence Dorr, who notes, "you don't need any explanation, just order something; it is all great!!!"

Whether you're returning for your favorite homemade bread or eager to try something new off the ever-rotating menu, each visit promises to be a delightful surprise. People like Elena Comiskey have fond memories of the cafe, reminiscing about “outstanding soups” that continue to linger long after they've departed. It's this level of love and dedication to crafting exceptional meals that keeps visitors coming back, even after they’ve moved away.

This quaint cafe captures the essence of home cooking with a gourmet twist. The Bombay Duck Pickle Cafe isn't just a place to eat; it's an experience designed to comfort and delight. So the next time you find yourself in Carthage, don’t miss the chance to discover the incredible offerings waiting for you at this unique establishment – your taste buds will thank you!

Service options
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
Offerings
Coffee
Dining options
Lunch
Dessert
84 Reviews
Miguel Ortiz

22 Sep 2025

An oasis of exciting ethnic flavors amidst a desert of monotonous American fare. Don't let the name fool you. This restaurant offers far more than just curry and naan. The special of the day was a Turkish appetizer spread, the likes of which I have not experienced since my travels abroad (see picture). All the food is made in-house and the care and attention to detail is reflected in the flavor and quality of the food. Bombay Duck Pickle Cafe offers customers an escape from the humdrum of pizza, burgers, mac n cheese, and Chinese takeout that dominates the restaurant scene in the local area. How expensive is a plate of this culinary escapism? The pictured and aforementioned Turkish appetizer spread special cost the writer just under $15; a small price to pay to experience authentic foreign flavors and be transported to distant lands by way of food. The restaurant is cash only, so be sure to stop by an ATM. Lunch service begins at 11:30 and takeout orders can be placed by phone. I cannot wait to return to Bombay Duck Pickle Cafe and see what taste travels they will take me on next.

Nicholas Heffron

22 Aug 2025

Loved this place, owner is delightful to talk to and the food was wonderful. Menu changes daily so it's a pleasant surprise each time you walk in the door

Becky Farmer

02 Aug 2025

Excellent food! The bread is fantastic, warm soft and buttery! Also the red curry coconut bisque hit the spot!

Elena Comiskey

01 Aug 2025

Consistently amazing food, even years apart! We lived in Carthage for 4 years and loved visiting Allison and Ralph for their incredible soups and rolls. Since moving away 2 years ago, our tastebuds have been sad and missing BDP. Today’s lunch of OUTSTANDING SOUPS was just what we needed. Thank you for the amazing lunch and for keeping our kids entertained while we drooled over our food.

James Kearney

20 Jul 2025

Top best eating experiences. Where homemade comfort meets a quirky, gourmet delivery.

Kathryn Jeurissen

04 Jul 2025

The menu changes with the season so all the food is fresh and made to order. No matter what you like or your diet is you can find an amazing meal here. The owners make everything fresh in the open kitchen, they are very hospitable and welcoming to all. This restaurant is well worth the trip from near and far.

Maria Held

24 Jun 2025

I still think about the lemongrass soup and all the amazing meals I had there sad when I moved away. The best restaurant in all of central New York was tucked away in Carthage.

Lawrence Dorr

01 Jun 2025

The food from this restaurant is amazing. Truly some of the best food I have ever eaten. This is a small cafe with 11 seats and nice decor. The owners are very nice and Allison is happy to explain any questions you may have about the diverse menu. To be completely honest, you don't need any explanation, just order something, it is all great!!! The rotating menu usually consists of 2 lunch specials, that generally come with sides and salad. The menu also has 5 or 6 different incredible soups. They bring fresh bread to the table, and have homemade deserts as well. The best part is that they feature flavors from around the world. The food is fresh, local, and all prepared in the restaurant. Eat in or take out. You will be kicking yourself for not trying it earlier.

Join the Bombay Duck Pickle Cafe Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.